First Congregational Church, United Church of Christ
Columbus, Ohio
1852-Present
First Congregational Church, United Church of Christ
Columbus, Ohio 1852-Present
The history of First Congregational Church, United Church of Christ – the beautiful Gothic cathedral on E. Broad Street in downtown Columbus, Ohio – is a rich one indeed.
Its trajectory reflects that of other Christian churches until the 16th century Protestant Reformation. In the 17th century, Presbyterians and Congregationalists journeyed to America. By the late 1849s, they were established in Columbus.
In 2027, First Congregational Church will celebrate its 175th anniversary. And so, to recount its history, we must go back to 1852 and even earlier.
The early years – 1852-1882
The congregation’s history begins in the hearts and minds of faithful dissent. By the late 1840s, a growing movement of Christian abolitionists was gaining strength in the struggle against slavery. These abolitionists could no longer abide in the union of Christian faith and a nation filled with slaves and slave-owners. In Columbus, in 1852, a cluster of such believers from Second Presbyterian Church decided that they were Congregational at heart and they parted amicably with Second Presbyterian to form the Third Presbyterian Church. Forty-two people transferred membership on Friday, September 24, 1852; the members of Second Presbyterian Church sent them off with this benediction:
“In view of the importance of this occasion, we add our expression of sympathy with those who leave us and an earnest desire that the great Head of the Church may be with them and help them. May He make them a church of His own, to glorify Him and promote His Kingdom in the world! May those who remain and those who go, when toil is here finished, meet in heaven, and together form a part of the church triumphant there!”
With a $1,000 loan provided by their brethren from Second Presbyterian, the newly formed church purchased a lot on the northeast corner of Third Street and Lynn Alley in downtown Columbus. There a frame chapel was erected. A formal call was extended to The Rev. William H. Marble. Under Rev. Marble’s leadership, the chapel was dedicated on July 11, 1852, and the congregation first worshiped in their new chapel on Sunday, September 26, 1852. The official charter of organization was signed on Wednesday, September 29, 1852.
By 1856, the church was renamed The First Congregational Church, Columbus. With membership steadily increasing, First Church was entertaining plans for a more spacious building. Henry C. Bowen, a leading Congregationalist, advised them to “buy a lot facing your State House and build a good building. The bravest policy is the best.” With the purchase of land directly across from the Ohio State House in 1856, members began to plan to build under the leadership of their new pastor, The Rev. J.M. Steele. Five months into his pastorate, the Rev. Steele set out for New York City to raise $7,000 for the Norman-style building. Tragically, he contracted smallpox and died shortly thereafter. The church pressed on and erected a building at 73 E. Broad Street. It was dedicated on December 23, 1857.
A succession of ministers followed: Henry Elliot, from October 1858 until August 1860; Edwin Goodwin, from October 1860 until December 1867; George Phillips, from March 1868 until September 1871; and Robert Hutchins from August 1872 until May 1882.
The Rev. Elliot was said to be a deeply spiritual man, but a person who was theologically and socially conservative.
The Rev. Dr. Goodwin arrived in Columbus within a month of the election of Abraham Lincoln. An active abolitionist, Dr. Goodwin preached with purpose. Throughout the Civil War, he visited camps and field hospitals, caring for the soldiers. Under his guiding hand, the church grew, even during war. When President Lincoln was assassinated and his body was moved from Washington, D.C., to Springfield, Ill., Dr. Goodwin was one of only two Ohio pastors to lead the service for almost 100,000 people on Capital Square in Columbus on April 29, 1865.
The Rev. George Phillips followed with his short, but effective and persuasive ministry.
During the nearly 10-year tenure of the Rev. Dr. Robert Hutchins, the church continued to grow and prosper. More than 390 new members had joined First Church. Historians say that Dr. Hutchins started First Church on its path of furthering the social gospel. After the church’s first 30 years in Columbus, more than 1,000 people had signed the rolls of membership for The First Congregational Church.
The Gladden legacy – 1882-1918
In December 1882, the Rev. Dr. Washington Gladden followed in the footsteps of his Williams College classmate, Robert Hutchins, and came to First Church. This seventh pastor of First Congregational Church presided over one of the most remarkable pastorates in the history of the American church. Throughout his 32-year tenure, the church grew in numbers and influence.
Dr. Gladden drew throngs of hearers. For many years his sermon was reprinted the following Monday upon the front page of the Ohio State Journal, the city’s leading newspaper. Dr. Gladden’s reputation grew across the country.
Dr. Gladden was ahead of his time in understanding the concept of the social gospel: the Gospel is not intended merely for the salvation of individuals but also for the transformation of society. No discussion of what has come to be known as the Social Gospel can be complete without the mention of Washington Gladden. Jacob Dorn, Dr. Gladden’s biographer, stated that for Washington Gladden “the personal and the social were in symbiotic relationship. One could not separate one’s own salvation from that of the world.” On Sunday mornings Dr. Gladden preached devotional sermons on prayer, the Bible, evangelism, and missions. On Sunday evenings, a different congregation gathered as he spoke on themes including collective bargaining, house inspection, the need for pure milk, elections, coal miner and streetcar worker strikes, the treatment of Blacks, and questions of war and peace.
Washington Gladden would have become president of The Ohio State University except for the grudges that some nursed against him for his prophetic stands defending Roman Catholics from demagogic assault and attacking Congregationalism’s use of John D. Rockefeller’s (Standard Oil) “tainted money.”
Perhaps the greatest impact Dr. Gladden had on Christendom was his deep and abiding development of liberal theology. Since the Great Awakening in the 1740s, Congregationalism had divided into distinct factions. New Light supporters of the revival reaffirmed the central importance of conversion, emphasizing the effective and experiential dimensions of the Christian life, while Old Light opponents stressed “rational and developmental aspects.” With the departure of the Unitarians from Congregationalism in 1825, the rift between liberals and orthodox concerning the Trinity, the nature of humankind, and the doctrine of grace became pronounced. By the late 1880s Dr. Gladden and Horace Bushnell led a major movement in Congregationalism that embraced liberal approaches to biblical scholarship and the Social Gospel.
During the 1902 Golden Jubilee Gala Celebration, Dr. Gladden spoke with love and thanksgiving of First Church and his pulpit:
“…you have given me an absolutely free pulpit. In times of theological transition, in times of social upheaval, when the air has been full of clashing opinions, I have never had any sense of limitations here. I have always spoken as freely as I desired to speak. You have not always agreed with me; you could not; but when my words, and sometimes my conduct were opposed to your thoughts and interests, you never tried to muzzle me, you have believed in my sincerity and faithful efforts, and the bonds of friendship have not been broken.”
Gladden was the author of music, poetry, and some 40 books; he was a friend to United States presidents including Theodore Roosevelt; he was frequently referred to as “Columbus’ First Citizen;” he was the founder of at least six churches in the Columbus area including Dublin Community Church.
After 32 years at the helm of First Congregational Church, Gladden retired in 1914 and was named Minister Emeritus. He died July 2, 1918.
He is buried in Greenlawn Cemetery in Columbus, where a mounted plaque bears his likeness along with highlights from his life. In 2018, the Washington Gladden Social Justice Park, named for the long-serving minister and champion of social justice, was dedicated. This green space lies directly west of the church on E. Broad Street. (See the description below.)
From Gladden to Lichliter – From Capital Square to Gothic Cathedral, 1918-1942
In 1911, the Rev. Carl Patton came from Ann Arbor, Michigan, to serve as an associate minister on the staff of First Church. He served under Dr. Gladden until 1914 when Gladden became the first minister emeritus. Rev. Patton was a man of common sense, cordiality, wit, and good humor. Doubtless, the burden of following so long and so distinguished a pastorate contributed to his decision to accept a call to serve First Congregational in Los Angeles in 1917.
The Rev. Irving Maurer followed in 1918. A friendly and genial man, and a gifted orator, he carried on Dr. Gladden’s crusade of social responsibility. While pastor, he also served as president of the Columbus Urban League.
After First Church, Rev. Maurer became president of Beloit College in Wisconsin.
In 1924, The Rev. Dr. McIlyar H. Lichliter, a modest man, and superb preacher, became minister. With no choir, Dr. Lichliter’s services were almost entirely built around preaching. He served until 1942, and it was under his leadership that plans began to take shape to construct the Neo-Gothic cathedral, the present-day home of First Church.
The cathedral, in memory of Dr. Gladden, was built during the Great Depression. It was designed by the eminent architect John Russell Pope and built for more than $1 million. It was dedicated on December 6, 1931.
The architecture was intended to represent the universality of the Gospel’s appeal. Some congregants called it a “Cathedral of Grace” and others referred to it as “our Gothic Beauty.” The cathedral is certainly an important legacy of Dr. Lichliter.
The Merrill and Coe Years, 1943-1983
In 1943, a popular lecturer and preacher, The Rev. Dr. Boynton Merrill became minister. Dr. Merrill was the editor of the worship material in the back of the 1934 Pilgrim Hymnal. He also wrote the booklet of prayers for soldiers fighting in World War II. Under his leadership, the debt on the building was retired.
Those who remember Boynton Merrill recall his passion for aesthetics, especially poetry. He was passionate about the church’s music and incorporating it beautifully in worship. During his first week in March 1943, he wrote a letter to the congregation: “I tell you, you have a beautiful church. We must conspire together to set that beauty free. For when beauty’s wings are spread and beauty’s face is seen, men may not call it God, but in their hearts, they know that it is.”
In his closing words in The First Church News on September 27, 1959, Dr. Merrill wrote: “Only as we know the Church will we love her and only as we love her will we serve her. And, as we serve her, we will serve Him to whom this Church really belongs and for the sake of whose Kingdom of Love and Righteousness she exists.”
In late December 1959, First Church voted to call the Rev. Dr. Chalmers Coe from his post in homiletics at Hartford Seminary in Connecticut. To become the minister at First Church meant foregoing his appointment to become dean of the seminary. He came from a family of great preachers and he himself was a formidable intellect. During the 1960s Civil Rights Movement, Dr. Coe was a prophet for social justice.
During Rev. Coe’s tenure, First Congregational Church of Columbus voted to join the United Church of Christ. During his tenure, the Christian Education wing was added in 1964, the Beckerath organ was built in 1972, and “The Days of Creation” Clerestory windows were added between 1976-1983. Following his distinguished ministry in 1983, the congregation voted to honor Dr. Coe as Minister Emeritus; he joined Dr. Merrill, Dr. Lichliter and Dr. Washington Gladden with that title.
The Rosenberger and Tschannen-Moran Years – 1985-2000
The youngest person to be called in this distinguished tradition of ministers was 30-year-old Rev. Dale Rosenberger. During his tenure, the title was changed to Senior Minister. He served from April 1985 until December 1992. This young and vibrant pastor oversaw mission and membership growth. Bethlehem on Broad Street, a Christmas day celebration for those in need, was started during his ministry. The church also became deeply involved in Habitat for Humanity, helping to house those also in need.
The Rev. Robert Tschannen-Moran followed and served from November 1993 until February 1998. He came to First Church from a significant street ministry that he founded and directed in Chicago, Ill. Rev. Tschannen-Moran brought organizational skill, a missional vision and zeal for evangelical faith to the pulpit of First Church. During his tenure, a much-needed capital campaign raised more than $1.5 million: the sanctuary roof was replaced, and the interior was completely restored. Air conditioning, a new sound system, and other improvements were added. Rev. Tschannen-Moran demonstrated a passion for the poor, compassion for gay and lesbian Christians, and his ability to welcome all people to the church.
The Ahrens Years – 2000-2025
The Rev. Timothy C. Ahrens was called to First Church in January 2000. He was the fifth consecutive senior minister from Yale Divinity School and was a lifelong member of the United Church of Christ. In his first few years, the church added more than 180 adult members and 70 children to the membership. On September 8, 2002, the church adopted an Open and Affirming statement, extending welcome to all persons of faith, genders and persuasions. Ahrens worked as a leader in B.R.E.A.D. (Building Responsibility, Equality and Dignity), a non-profit organization addressing community problems.
Under Rev. Ahrens’ leadership, the lot directly west of the church building was purchased and construction began on the Washington Gladden Social Justice Park. (See below) The park was a physical reminder of how Rev. Ahrens continued to further the church’s legacy in preaching and teaching for social justice throughout his ministry.
Rev. Ahrens, author of newspaper columns and books, researched and wrote a good portion of this church history.
He retired in 2025. Following his retirement, the Rev. Becky David served as interim senior minister with the Rev. jessica young chang as interim associate minister.
Music, Art and Outreach Programs
First Congregational Church has long had a reputation for excellent music and art incorporated into worship and presented in special events. The website firstchurcharts.org lists the concert series and other information. A history of First Church music and the many organists and choir directors who have contributed to its excellence can be found at first-church.org. Also, a book about the art at First Church is being compiled and published.
Among the many outreach and mission programs that First Church has been involved with for decades are these:
Gladden Community House; Godman Guild; Neighborhood Nursery; Downtown PlaySchool; Bethlehem on Broad Street; Good Samaritan Fund; Deep Griha Society; Pretiola Shop; CATALYST; and Habitat for Humanity.
The Washington Gladden Social Justice Park
Located at 404 E. Broad Street, the park, named for Washington Gladden, is the first in the United States devoted to the concept of social justice. It is an 18,000 square feet green space built on what used to be a used car lot. It is advertised as “an oasis of hope that honors those who have advanced social justice while shining a light on the work that continues today.” Included are trees, backdrops honoring social justice leaders and themes, and a “Pathway of Justice” with steppingstones bearing quotations from leaders. The sculpture, “A Single Garment of Destiny” references Martin Luther King Jr.’s quotation.
The driving forces behind the park were church members Thomas Worley, Charles Weaver and Rev. Ahrens, along with the financial contributions of the Jeffrey and Crane families. For more information about the park, go to www.socialjusticepark.org.